Welcome to our definitive ranking of all L.A. Noire cases from worst to best. If you’ve ever found yourself immersed in the meticulously recreated 1940s Los Angeles, solving crimes alongside Detective Cole Phelps, you’ll know the game’s narrative depth and intricacies are what truly set it apart. But not all cases in Rockstar’s masterpiece deliver the same level of excitement and engagement. Some cases stand as remarkable shows of storytelling and intrigue, while others might leave you feeling underwhelmed.

Our detailed ranking dives into every single case, from the mind-bending mysteries of the Homicide Desk to the complex conspiracies unraveled on the Arson Desk. We aim to provide a comprehensive look at what makes each case tick, considering aspects like plot twists, character development, and how well they leverage the game’s unique mechanics, such as facial animation technology.

For instance, remember the first tutorial-driven Traffic Desk case, 'The Driver’s Seat'? It’s a great introduction to the game’s mechanics but falls short in terms of narrative complexity when compared to more intense cases like 'The Quarter Moon Murders,' an unforgettable journey into the mind of a serial killer. By examining these cases side by side, we aim to give you, the reader, a well-rounded perspective on why some cases might captivate you more than others.

We also look at how each case contributes to the overarching story arc. Some seemingly minor cases contain clues that hint at the game’s larger conspiracies, making them more significant upon reflection. For example, 'The Golden Butterfly' may not appear crucial at first glance, but its implications resonate throughout the Homicide Desk's narrative.

No matter if you’re a seasoned sleuth revisiting the dark alleys and sunlit boulevards of L.A. Noire, or a newcomer eager to jump into this noir adventure for the first time, our ranking offers valuable insights. Join us as we spotlight the highs and lows, revealing the hidden gems and highlighting the inevitable duds in this iconic detective saga.

Buckle up your trench coat, grab your notepad, and get ready to dive into the gritty world of 1940s Los Angeles crime. This journey through L.A. Noire’s cases will not only help you appreciate the game’s nuance but also prepare you for the challenges that lie ahead in your investigative endeavors.

Introduction to L A Noire Case Rankings

Welcome, detective, to our comprehensive guide on the L.A. Noire case rankings. As a gaming aficionado, you'll appreciate the intricate tapestries of mystery and suspense woven into each scenario of RockStar Games' beloved crime-solving title. Whether you're revisiting old favorites or diving in for the first time, this guide will help you navigate the rich narrative and challenging puzzles that make up every case in L.A. Noire.

In L.A. Noire, you step into the polished shoes of Detective Cole Phelps, a former Marine turned LAPD officer. The game offers a series of compelling cases across different desks such as Traffic, Homicide, Vice, and Arson. Each case shines with its own unique story, characters, and complexities. However, not all cases are created equal; some stand head and shoulders above the rest in terms of plot, interrogation mechanics, and overall enjoyment.

So, what criteria do we use to determine these rankings? First, and most crucial, is storyline. A gripping narrative packed with unexpected twists and turns keeps us glued to the controller. Next, the difficulty level matters. The best cases strike the perfect balance, challenging you without becoming frustratingly hard. Additionally, presentation and graphics play key roles; from meticulously detailed crime scenes to atmospheric settings, these elements immerse you deeper into 1940s Los Angeles. Lastly, we consider replayability. The true test of a great case is its ability to lure us back for another round of sleuthing.

For example, cases like "The White Shoe Slaying" on the Homicide desk stand out for its intricate plot and memorable characters. Another prime candidate for high ranking is "A Different Kind of War" under the Arson desk, delivering a deeply satisfying conclusion to the game's overarching narrative. These examples show how some cases can captivate our imagination and challenge our detective skills more effectively than others.

As we journey through the L.A. Noire case rankings, keep in mind that our list aims to highlight the crème de la crème while offering insights into what makes each case publish-worthy. Whether you agree or vehemently disagree with our rankings, one thing is certain: every case in L.A. Noire contributes to one of the most memorable gaming experiences of all time.

Summary:

• The guide on L.A. Noire case rankings explores the intricate narratives and challenging puzzles that make each case unique, focusing on Detective Cole Phelps' experiences across various departments.
• Key criteria for ranking include storyline, difficulty level, presentation, graphics, and replayability, with top cases like "The White Shoe Slaying" and "A Different Kind of War" standing out.
• This list aims to highlight the best cases, offering insights into their appeal and contributing to L.A. Noire's memorable gaming experience.

The Method Behind the Rankings

When it comes to ranking the cases in L.A. Noire, our process involves several key factors to ensure accuracy and engagement. Each case is dissected based on five main criteria: storyline, gameplay mechanics, character development, detective work, and replayability. Let's delve into the method we use to evaluate each case, ensuring that our rankings are fair and insightful.

The storyline is paramount. We assess how well the narrative is constructed, considering plot twists, dialogue quality, and overall immersion. For instance, a case like "The Red Lipstick Murder" scores high due to its intense atmosphere and gripping narrative that keeps players on their toes.

Next, the gameplay mechanics are vital. We examine how well the case integrates the core gameplay elements of investigation and interrogation. A case that allows for creative problem-solving and varied interaction points is ranked higher. Think of "The Golden Butterfly," where you must use meticulous detective work to piece together seemingly unrelated clues.

Character development also plays a critical role in our rankings. We evaluate how well the case contributes to the growth and depth of both the protagonist and supporting characters. For example, "A Walk in Elysian Fields" delves deep into the protagonist Cole Phelps' psyche, providing a rich backstory that enhances the overall experience.

We then look at the detective work involved in each case. This includes the complexity of the clues and the satisfaction of solving the puzzles. Detailed cases like "The Quarter Moon Murders," with its intricate clues and challenging puzzles, tend to score higher.

Finally, replayability is considered. We gauge whether the case has elements that entice players to return and experience it multiple times, perhaps to uncover missed clues or dialogues. "The Silk Stocking Murder," loaded with numerous side clues and optional dialogue paths, is a prime example of a highly replayable case.

By meticulously evaluating each aspect, we ensure our rankings of L.A. Noire cases are comprehensive and valuable to fans of the game. This methodical approach provides a balanced and nuanced view, making our rankings both credible and engaging.

Summary:

• Rankings are based on storyline, gameplay mechanics, character development, detective work, and replayability.
• Cases like "The Red Lipstick Murder" are praised for their intense atmosphere and gripping narrative.
• Elements such as intricate clues in "The Quarter Moon Murders" and replayable content in "The Silk Stocking Murder" contribute to higher scores.

The Worst L A Noire Cases of All Time

When we’re diving into the world of L.A. Noire, not all cases deliver the same level of excitement, challenge, or intrigue. Among the 21 cases, some just don’t hit the mark. Here are the worst L.A. Noire cases of all time ranked.

Manifest Destiny stands out for all the wrong reasons. Despite its climactic placement in the storyline, the case is riddled with convoluted elements and lacks a cohesive narrative. The investigation feels more like a mishmash of suspects and red herrings than a coherent story. For example, when you interrogate LAPD Officer Del Gado, the dialogue can feel forced, and the connections between leads are tenuous at best. There's an overwhelming sense that the developers threw in too many twists for the sake of complexity, ultimately muddling the narrative.

The Quarter Moon Murders could have been a thrilling treasure hunt but ended up being monotonous. The case involves a series of letter-based clues from a murderer, leading protagonist Cole Phelps on a long and often tedious journey around Los Angeles. While the idea of a poetic scavenger hunt sounds intriguing, it becomes repetitive quickly. The letters themselves are lengthy, and some clues are painfully obscure, making it feel more like a slog than a riveting chase. The pacing grinds to a halt as you backtrack across familiar locations, decreasing the overall engagement.

In The Driver's Seat, the first case in L.A. Noire's Traffic Desk, the case itself suffers from a lacklustre narrative and uninspired puzzle mechanics. Sure, it serves as an introduction to the game’s mechanics, but it does little to engage experienced players. The investigation into the hit-and-run of Adrian Black quickly unravels into a cliched and predictable story involving domestic issues and infidelity. There's no real sense of accomplishment upon solving it, which leaves players feeling underwhelmed right from the start.

Perhaps one of the most disjointed cases is The Black Caesar. The case involves a narcotics ring that revolves around a jazz club, but it suffers from a severe identity crisis. The convoluted twists about counterfeit military surplus morphine overshadow the potential depth of the story. For instance, tracking down Fleetwood Morgan through a series of loosely related clues and uninspired chases feels like filler rather than integral to the plot progression. The whole experience can leave players scratching their heads without a sense of closure.

Lastly, The Fallen Idol stands as one of the most forgettable cases in the game. Driving into Hollywood, the case begins with the discovery of a young girl and an aspiring actress who have mysteriously crashed a car off an escarpment. The resulting investigation more or less plays out with minimal player agency, culminating in a rather bland and predictable fashion. The alleged involvement of movie director Mark Bishop never truly feels gripping, leaving players more annoyed by the sudden twists rather than intrigued.

While L.A. Noire offers some stellar storytelling and captivating cases, not all manage to deliver the same level of excellence. These particular cases not only detract from the overall experience but also serve as a reminder that even the most immersive games can stumble.

Summary:

• "Manifest Destiny" is overly convoluted with forced dialogue and unnecessary twists, muddling the narrative.
• "The Quarter Moon Murders" offers a repetitive and monotonous scavenger hunt, bogged down by lengthy letters and obscure clues.
• "The Driver's Seat" lacks engaging narrative and puzzle mechanics, resulting in a clichéd, predictable storyline.

Low-Ranked Traffic Desk Cases

When diving into the depths of L.A. Noire, it is impossible to ignore the Traffic Desk cases. Though short in stature, these cases define the rookie experience for Cole Phelps. But not all Traffic Desk cases shine equally. Today, we look at the low-ranked Traffic Desk cases, explaining why they pale in comparison to their more illustrious counterparts.

First on our list is "The Drivers Seat." This case starts with a bang but fizzles out quickly. The plot follows the investigation of a stolen vehicle, which at first glance, seems intriguing. However, it devolves into a mundane fetch-quest structure. I find it lacks the complexity and twists that make other cases compelling. The interrogations are straightforward, providing little challenge or excitement. By the end, you uncover the truth, but the journey there leaves much to be desired.

Next is "The Fallen Idol." This case promises a lot but ultimately fails to deliver. It involves a dramatic car crash and a seemingly glamorous Hollywood scandal. Unfortunately, the pacing falters, making the detective work feel tedious. The constant back-and-forth between locations grows tiresome, and the suspect interviews feel repetitive. Despite the promising premise, "The Fallen Idol" ends up being one of the weaker links in the Traffic Desk chain.

Another case that merits a spot on this list is "A Slip of the Tongue." It revolves around a car theft ring, which sounds exciting, but the execution leaves much on the table. The investigation is cluttered with prolonged chase sequences that feel like filler rather than essential parts of the story. Plus, the characters lack depth, particularly the suspects, who could have been far more engaging. It is a missed opportunity to add richness to the early game.

Last but not least, we have "The Golden Butterfly." This case introduces a level of brutality with a murdered woman, drawing a lot of initial intrigue. Yet, it quickly stagnates. The clues are too obvious, making it simple to connect the dots without much effort. Also, the story does not integrate well with the overarching narrative of L.A. Noire. It feels like a standalone episode rather than a critical piece of Cole Phelps journey. The absence of meaningful character development and lack of plot twists make this a rather perfunctory case.

In conclusion, while these low-ranked Traffic Desk cases have their moments, they lack the dynamism and depth that make L.A. Noires better cases memorable. But they do serve a purpose, setting the stage for more intricate mysteries to come. If you are replaying the game or tackling it for the first time, be patient; the more rewarding experiences await you beyond the Traffic Desk.

Summary:

• "The Drivers Seat" starts strong with a stolen vehicle investigation but lacks depth and excitement, turning into a mundane fetch-quest.
• "The Fallen Idol" has a promising Hollywood scandal setup but is let down by tedious pacing and repetitive suspect interviews.
• "A Slip of the Tongue" and "The Golden Butterfly" offer initially intriguing plots but suffer from shallow characters, obvious clues, and lack of meaningful narrative integration.

Unremarkable Homicide Desk Cases

When it comes to ranking all L.A. Noire cases from worst to best, the Homicide Desk has its share of less-than-thrilling investigations. While the game excels at narrative depth and historical detail, a few cases under this desk feel somewhat unremarkable compared to others.

One such case is "The Red Lipstick Murder." The premise sets it up to be a gripping tale, but, in execution, it falls flat. The victim, found in a ravine, points to a possible serial killer, and I anticipated an adrenaline-fueled chase for a sadistic criminal. Instead, the investigation trudges through a series of monotonous interrogations and clue-hunting that lacks intensity. The killer, it turns out, is yet another run-of-the-mill criminal without much backstory, making the resolution feel anticlimactic.

Similarly, "The Golden Butterfly" fails to make a memorable impact. It starts intriguingly enough with the brutal murder of a mother, but soon devolves into predictable gameplay patterns. There's no shortage of suspects, from the husband to a shady character spotted near the crime scene, but neither the storyline nor the characters involved lend much depth to the case. As a player, I felt like I was just going through the motions, a sentiment echoed by many.

Even "The White Shoe Slaying" doesn't escape the list of unremarkable homicide cases. The investigation begins with the discovery of a woman found strangled near a shoe store. The search for witnesses and evidence feels tediously repetitive. Sifting through the victim's belongings leads us to unravel some irrelevant backstories before finally zeroing in on a suspect who barely leaves an impression. The lack of a personal connection or compelling twist makes this one easily forgettable.

Another case that falls short is "The Silk Stocking Murder." At first glance, it seems complex, with elements of a gruesome crime scene and cryptic messages left by the killer. However, as the investigation progresses, it becomes just another formulaic hunt for clues spread over multiple locations. The interrogation scenes lack the tension and uncertainty that usually keep me on the edge of my seat, and the culprit's motives are disappointingly shallow.

In revisiting these cases, it's clear that while L.A. Noire has many highlights, the Homicide Desk also has its fair share of lackluster moments. These unremarkable cases, with their predictable patterns and uninspiring characters, underscore how important it is for a game to balance story depth with engaging gameplay mechanics. Though each case had the potential for greatness, they ended up being mere shadows of what they could have been.

Summary:

• Several cases under L.A. Noire's Homicide Desk, such as "The Red Lipstick Murder" and "The Silk Stocking Murder," suffer from repetitive and monotonous gameplay that fails to deliver the expected intensity and depth.
• "The Golden Butterfly" and "The White Shoe Slaying" also fall short, with predictable patterns and uninspiring characters that make the investigations feel like going through the motions.
• While L.A. Noire excels in narrative depth, these Homicide Desk cases highlight the need for a balance between story and engaging gameplay to avoid falling into predictability and lack of substance.

Subpar Vice Desk Cases and Why They Fall Short

While L.A. Noire offers a myriad of intriguing cases, the Vice desk sometimes stumbles with its execution. Let's dive into some of the Subpar Vice Desk Cases and analyze why they fall short.

First up, "The Set Up." This case initially promises an exciting blend of boxing intrigue and mob entanglements, but it fumbles with convoluted plot points. I found myself frequently retracing steps due to unclear objectives. For example, during the investigation, you're tasked with finding a suspect in a chaotic gym environment. The lack of clear indicators on where to go next often led to frustrating moments of aimless wandering.

Another letdown is "The Naked City." Despite an engaging premise involving the death of a starlet, the case unravels with too many forced connections. Imagine chasing a lead based on flimsy evidence, only to end up interrogating multiple suspects who add little to the plot. The case’s downfall is its lack of coherent story development. I particularly recall an interrogation with a minor character who delivered irrelevant information, making the process feel like a wild goose chase rather than a calculated investigation.

Lastly, "Manifest Destiny" promises a gripping tale of drug smuggling and police corruption but delivers a predictable and somewhat bloated narrative. The inclusion of numerous characters makes it difficult to follow, and the resolution feels anticlimactic. For instance, after connecting dots between various gangs and corrupt officials, I expected a climactic showdown. Instead, it ended with a hurried conclusion that left me unsatisfied and questioning the hours spent tracing dull leads.

In essence, these Vice desk cases suffer from confusing plotlines, underwhelming conclusions, and moments of sheer frustration. They stand out in stark contrast to the more polished cases found in the Homicide and Arson desks, making them the weaker links in an otherwise stellar game.

Summary:

• "The Set Up" has an enticing premise but suffers from convoluted plot points and unclear objectives, leading to frustrating aimless wandering.
• "The Naked City" starts strong with the death of a starlet but falters with forced connections and irrelevant interrogations, making investigations feel like a wild goose chase.
• "Manifest Destiny" introduces drug smuggling and police corruption but ends predictably and anticlimactically, burdened by a bloated narrative and difficult-to-follow character inclusions.

Disappointing Arson Desk Cases

The Arson Desk in L.A. Noire unfortunately leaves much to be desired, with several cases falling flat in both narrative engagement and gameplay mechanics. The three main arson cases—"The Gas Man," "A Walk in Elysian Fields," and "House of Sticks"—are prime examples of missed opportunities, often turning into a tedious blend of monotonous detectives' work and uninspired storytelling.

First up is "The Gas Man." In theory, unraveling a mystery involving a gas explosion should inject some excitement, but it instead becomes a slog through redundant interviews and predictable outcomes. The investigation pivots around a series of gas heaters, leading to an obvious conclusion without much flair. As I navigated through scenes laden with excessive, uninteresting dialogue, it felt more like a mechanical chore than an exhilarating detective mission.

Next is "A Walk in Elysian Fields," which had potential with its backdrop of a corporate conspiracy. However, it succumbs to a repetitive investigation pattern. The case starts intriguingly with a house fire that initially seems accidental but soon reveals layers of corruption. Sadly, the pacing drags with an overemphasis on searching similar crime scenes and questioning witnesses whose testimonies rarely offer new insights. What could have been a deep dive into corporate malfeasance turned into an exercise in tedium.

"House of Sticks" further underscores the weaknesses in the Arson Desk. The narrative begins to feel convoluted, as threads of previous cases haphazardly intertwine. The case loses focus amidst numerous subplots, leading to a fragmented and unsatisfying experience. Driving from one dilapidated house to another, piecing together clues that often lead to dead-ends, strained my patience. By the end, I was left with the distinct impression that the developers ran out of fresh ideas, recycling old ones instead.

Overall, the Arson Desk breaks the immersive experience that other desks in L.A. Noire manage to embody. It’s disheartening, considering the game's rich setting and high potential for riveting detective stories. I wanted to delve into a labyrinth of pyromania and subterfuge but ended up untangling threads that unraveled too easily, with none of the dynamism or surprise that makes for memorable gameplay. For a game that often shines, the Arson Desk serves as a glaring weak point.

Summary:

• The Arson Desk in L.A. Noire is criticized for its lackluster narrative and repetitive gameplay, with cases like "The Gas Man" delivering predictable outcomes and monotonous tasks.
• "A Walk in Elysian Fields" and "House of Sticks" fail to maintain engagement due to their slow pacing, repetitive investigations, and fragmented storytelling, detracting from the overall experience.
• The Arson Desk is a weak point in L.A. Noire, lacking the immersive and dynamic detective work found in other parts of the game, leaving players underwhelmed and disappointed.

Mid-Tier Traffic Desk Assignments

The middle-of-the-road cases in L.A. Noire pack a mix of highs and lows, providing glimpses of brilliance while sometimes faltering in execution. These cases serve as the backbone of the game, and while they might not be show-stoppers, they definitely have their moments of intrigue.

In "The Fallen Idol," we delve into Hollywood's shadier side. This Traffic Desk case kicks off with a car in flames and quickly morphs into a scandalous tale involving underage actresses and shady movie moguls. What truly elevates this case is the distinct Los Angeles setting. Iconic landmarks like Grauman's Chinese Theatre add authentic flavor. However, the plot can feel convoluted, bogged down by numerous interrogations that sometimes lead to dead ends.

"A Marriage Made in Heaven" stands out thanks to its intriguing crime scene and plot twists. This case begins with a hit-and-run outside a bar and quickly spirals into domestic drama and infidelity. It's rich in unexpected turns but stumbles with the gameplay mechanics. The courtroom-style questioning can feel monotonous after a while. However, the strong narrative elements make it a memorable mid-tier assignment. The chase sequence through the city streets is particularly thrilling, combining action with detective work in a satisfying mix.

One of the stronger chapters in the Traffic Desk lineup is "The Red Lipstick Murder." This case brings out the serial killer trope but with a unique twist. The crime scene investigation is absorbing, and the use of the Black Dahlia as inspiration gives it a chilling realism. The case's major drawback lies in its pacing. The meticulous clue-hunting can drag, making it a bit tedious compared to the more dynamic cases. Yet, this assignment is worth it for the psychological depth it adds to the overall narrative.

In "The Studio Secretary Murder," another exemplary Traffic Desk case, you face a homicide with layers of deception. The victim is a secretary with a secret, and unraveling her life reveals the double lives many characters lead. The strength here lies in its character interactions. The suspects are well-developed, making interrogations engaging. However, it falls short in action sequences, which can feel forced and out of place in an otherwise strong narrative-driven case.

"The Driver's Seat" hits the mid-tier mark with a blend of investigation and action. Starting with the discovery of a stolen vehicle and escalating into a deeper criminal conspiracy, this case keeps you on your toes. The blend of car chases, interrogations, and clue-finding makes for a well-rounded experience. However, the case can feel derivative, leaning heavily on familiar tropes without offering anything groundbreaking. Despite this, "The Driver's Seat" does enough to keep you engaged, even if it doesn't stand out.

These Traffic Desk cases might not all be stellar, but each brings something unique to the table, whether it's plot twists, rich settings, or compelling character arcs. They help pace the game, offering varied experiences while keeping the player invested in the overarching narrative of L.A. Noire.

Summary:

• The mid-tier cases in L.A. Noire such as "The Fallen Idol," "A Marriage Made in Heaven," and "The Red Lipstick Murder" provide engaging narratives with highs and lows, blending intrigue with occasional convolutions.
• Cases like "The Studio Secretary Murder" and "The Driver's Seat" feature strong character interactions and a mix of investigation and action, though they sometimes fall short in pacing and originality.
• Overall, these Traffic Desk assignments contribute unique elements, from plot twists to rich settings, keeping players invested in the game's overarching narrative.

Average Homicide Desk Cases

Transitioning from the Traffic Desk to the Homicide Desk amps up the stakes and complexity of L.A. Noire, but not all homicide cases are created equal. As each case delves into the seedy underbelly of 1940s Los Angeles, some stand out more than others.

Let's start with "The Red Lipstick Murder." It's an almost textbook example of what makes a homicide case in L.A. Noire both compelling and nerve-wracking. We follow the trail of a brutal murder that involves numerous crime scene investigations, from a bloody courtyard to a suspect's grim apartment. However, it sometimes feels drawn out by making you chase down numerous leads that end up being dead ends. The final confrontation redeems it somewhat, but the pacing lags.

Next up is "The Golden Butterfly." This case excels in its emotional weight, having us unravel the mystery surrounding the death of a mother found in an alleyway. The drama is heartfelt as we interview a grieving widower and a distressed daughter. The process of eliminating suspects and using clues like the butterfly brooch to narrow down the real culprit stands out. On the downside, the investigation can appear overly linear, making the discovery process a bit less rewarding.

Then there's "The Silk Stocking Murder," an intriguing case that dips into the dark side of the Hollywood dream. Its strength lies in the grisly crime scene details and the rich backstory of the victim's troubled life. We feel the weight of each clue, whether it's the victim's torn dress or the chain of pawn shops. However, certain players mention it's too easy to identify the murderer, diminishing the overall challenge and satisfaction.

"The White Shoe Slaying" offers complexity in both its plotting and evidence gathering. Chasing down multiple witnesses, parsing through conflicting testimonies, and engaging in tense interrogations make for an engrossing case. Yet, its key limitation lies in an over-reliance on the same suspect archetype, making it somewhat predictable.

Lastly, "The Studio Secretary Murder" gets mixed reviews. While it skillfully juggles multiple suspects and motives, the case can feel overly complicated and meandering, detracting from the enjoyment. Yes, the narrative depth is enriching, but sometimes it overreaches, losing players in its labyrinthine plot.

The average Homicide Desk cases in L.A. Noire invite us into a gritty, unforgiving world. They challenge us with moral quandaries and immersive details, even if they aren't always perfectly executed. However, they set a meaningful stage for both greater and lesser cases that unfold in this iconic game.

Summary:

• "The Red Lipstick Murder" is compelling with multiple crime scene investigations but suffers from pacing issues.
• "The Golden Butterfly" offers emotional depth and clear clues yet feels overly linear.
• "The Silk Stocking Murder" features detailed clues and backstory but is often too easy to solve.

Underwhelming Vice Desk Investigations

When it comes to the Vice Desk in L.A. Noire, I couldn't help but feel a sense of underwhelm throughout several of the investigations. Admittedly, Vice isn't about cops in shootouts; it's about digging through the murk of human vices. But here, the execution was a bit lackluster.

Take the case "The Black Caesar" for example. The concept of chasing down a drug ring embedded in Los Angeles sounds thrilling, but the gameplay quickly devolves into repetitious raids and uninspired clue searching. Although I appreciate the effort to immerse us in the underbelly of 1940s L.A., the endless roaming from one jazz club to another felt tedious. I wanted more narrative depth and less filler content.

Similarly, "The Set Up" left much to be desired. The storyline revolving around fixed boxing matches seemed ripe with potential for drama and intrigue. Unfortunately, the clues were too easy to piece together, making the case feel like a cakewalk rather than a challenging investigation. I breezed through conversations and interrogations without ever feeling truly engaged or tested. There was a sense of predictability that made the whole experience less satisfying.

Then there's "Manifest Destiny," the final case on the Vice Desk. While the narrative tries to wrap things up with a daring raid, the build-up lacks the emotional punch it aims for. The twist involving members of the LAPD being complicit in drug smuggling was predictable, and I couldn't help but feel disconnected from the climax. It's supposed to be this big reveal, but it falls flat due to insufficient character development and lackluster pacing.

Overall, while the Vice Desk had a few bright spots, most cases felt like missed opportunities. I constantly hoped for that moment of brilliance or that twist that would surprise me. Unfortunately, what I got were investigations that were often predictable, with underdeveloped characters and thin plotlines.

Summary:

• The Vice Desk cases in L.A. Noire are underwhelming, with repetitive gameplay and a lack of narrative depth.
• "The Black Caesar" and "The Set Up" have promising premises but suffer from tedious tasks and predictable storylines.
• The final case, "Manifest Destiny," fails to deliver an emotional punch due to predictable twists and poor character development.

Mediocre Arson Desk Cases

The Arson Desk in L.A. Noire has its fair share of highs and lows, but let’s dive into the more mediocre cases that just don’t stand up to the best. First off, we have "The Gas Man." This case starts off strong with a house explosion and a gruesome set of charred remains, but it loses steam quickly. The investigation feels repetitive as you search countless burnt-out crime scenes. Plus, the lack of substantial clues makes the whole affair drag on. It’s a textbook example of a mission that promises a lot yet delivers very little in the way of excitement or development.

Then there's "A Walk in Elysian Fields." This case is supposed to shine light on a larger conspiracy, but the execution leaves much to be desired. The dialogue gets bogged down in exposition, and the interrogations lack the punch that we’ve come to expect from the game. The climax feels forced and doesn’t provide the emotional or intellectual payoff one would hope for. It lacks the gripping chase sequences or dramatic confrontations that would make it memorable.

Lastly, we have "House of Sticks." While this case benefits from an interesting premise—investigating a series of arsons linked to insurance fraud—it falls short in terms of gameplay mechanics. The pattern becomes predictable as you visit one burnt house after another, each filled with the same types of clues and suspects. By the time you piece everything together, you’re left feeling more relieved that it’s over than satisfied by solving the puzzle.

These cases serve to flesh out the roster of missions in the Arson Desk, but they lack the dynamism and engaging elements of the game's finest moments. They're decent filler, but when ranking all L.A. Noire cases from worst to best, they unquestionably land in the lower tiers.

Summary:

• "The Gas Man" starts strong but quickly becomes repetitive with a lack of substantial clues, making the mission drag on.
• "A Walk in Elysian Fields" falls short with excessive exposition and lacks memorable chase sequences or confrontations.
• "House of Sticks" has an interesting premise but predictable gameplay, resulting in relief rather than satisfaction when completed.

Top Traffic Desk Cases That Excel

Landing a coveted spot among the Top Traffic Desk Cases is no small feat, but some investigations in 'L.A. Noire' truly excel in delivering a combination of intricate storytelling, clever puzzles, and high-stakes drama. Let's dive into the cases that set the bar high.

One standout case is "The Driver's Seat," where we unravel a complex hit-and-run involving Henry Arnett. This case captures the essence of a thrilling pursuit. The investigation starts with a seemingly straightforward vehicular accident but escalates into a multi-layered mystery. Searching Henry's apartment reveals clues and red herrings that keep you on your toes. The tension peaks with a heart-racing chase segment that perfectly balances adrenaline and narrative.

Next up is "A Marriage Made in Heaven." This case kicks off with a late-night collision that looks like a simple traffic incident but soon entangles multiple parties in a web of deceit and jealousy. The dynamic interrogation scenes here are where the game shines. For example, questioning Lorna Pattison unveils inconsistencies that you, as a detective, must meticulously pick apart. The interplay of truth and lies, especially during interviews with the victim's spouse and friends, makes this case a genuine masterclass in narrative gameplay.

"Manifest Destiny" earns its spot with an explosive mix of police corruption and drug trafficking. The intense shootouts and grim discoveries, such as finding morphine syrettes, highlight the darker underbelly of 1940s L.A. Each location investigated, from decrepit warehouses to lavish mansions, contributes to a rich tapestry that keeps the player engaged and invested. The layered story reveals itself gradually, rewarding keen-eyed detectives who pay attention to every detail.

In "The Fallen Idol," we delve into the seedy side of Hollywood. This case begins with a scandalous car accident that leads to a tale of exploitation and predatory behavior in the film industry. The interviews with characters like June Ballard and Jessica Hamilton are gripping, filled with tension and ethical gray areas. The puzzle-solving elements, where players must piece together evidence from crime scenes and witness statements, highlight the depth of L.A. Noire's Traffic Desk cases.

Lastly, "The Red Lipstick Murder" might technically fall under the Homicide Desk, but its influence on the Traffic Desk cases is undeniable. The level of detail in the crime scenes, such as blood trails and mysterious footprints, pushes you to think like a real detective. The atmospheric tension is palpable as you interrogate suspects and gather clues, culminating in a classic noir confrontation that ties all elements together beautifully.

While every Traffic Desk case in 'L.A. Noire' has its unique strengths, these top cases excel in crafting a captivating experience that blends narrative depth with engaging gameplay mechanics, setting a high standard for crime-solving adventures.

Summary:

• "The Driver's Seat" features a thrilling hit-and-run investigation that escalates with intricate clues and a heart-racing chase.
• "A Marriage Made in Heaven" showcases dynamic interrogations and a complex web of deceit, making it a masterclass in narrative gameplay.
• "Manifest Destiny," "The Fallen Idol," and "The Red Lipstick Murder" highlight deep narratives, intense action, and engaging puzzles that define the Traffic Desk cases.

Superb Homicide Desk Cases

When it comes to the Homicide Desk cases in L.A. Noire, there's a reason they stand out as some of the most compelling experiences in the game. These cases dive deep into gritty, realistic crime scenes and demand our utmost detective skills. Let's take a deeper look at some of the superb cases you shouldn't miss.

The Red Lipstick Murder sets an intense tone right from the start. In this case, we investigate the brutal killing of a young woman named Celine Henry. The crime scene is strikingly graphic, littered with disturbing details that require close examination. From a broken lipstick tube to a bloodstained shoe, every piece of evidence pulls us deeper into a web of deceit and violence. What's enthralling here is the atmosphere—the sense of creeping dread as we sift through clues and interrogate suspects.

Next, The Silk Stocking Murder takes psychological tension up a notch. Here, another woman, Eva Muller, is found murdered, and the suspect list includes some rather unsavory individuals. As we dig deeper, the connection to the Black Dahlia emerges, wrapping this case in a historical enigma. Moments like finding Eva's Bible or the chilling discovery of the silk stocking itself keep me glued to the screen, adding layers of intrigue and urgency.

The White Shoe Slaying is another standout that combines intricate narrative with meticulously designed crime scenes. This case involves the murder of Theresa Taraldsen, and it's one of those investigations where each detail matters. From piecing together Theresa's movements on the night of her death to interrogating a myriad of shady characters, this case exemplifies why the Homicide Desk cases are so unforgettable. It's exciting to see the tension ratchet up with every new reveal.

Finally, A Marriage Made in Heaven delivers a narrative punch that's hard to ignore. At first, it seems like a simple hit-and-run, but as we delve deeper, it reveals a subplot of infidelity and deceit. Each step, from the initial crime scene to grilling suspects, feels critical. Unraveling the truth behind the fragile facade of the victim's seemingly perfect life adds an emotional weight that's rare in many video games. The layers of complexity and human emotion make this case truly exceptional.

These are just a few examples of why the Homicide Desk cases in L.A. Noire stand head and shoulders above many other gaming experiences. Each case is a meticulously crafted story that pulls us in and keeps us on the edge of our seats, blending strong narrative elements with engaging, challenging detective work. It's no wonder they remain some of the most memorable moments in the game.

Summary:

• "The Red Lipstick Murder" offers an intense start with a brutally graphic crime scene involving Celine Henry, featuring key evidence like a broken lipstick tube and bloodstained shoe.
• "The Silk Stocking Murder" amps up the psychological tension with the murder of Eva Muller, drawing connections to the Black Dahlia mystery and featuring chilling finds like Eva's Bible and a silk stocking.
• "A Marriage Made in Heaven" begins with a hit-and-run but unravels into a complex subplot of infidelity and deceit, adding emotional weight and making each investigation step feel crucial.

Outstanding Vice Desk Investigations

The Vice Desk investigations in L.A. Noire offer some of the most compelling and morally complex cases in the game. As we rank these cases, it's evident why they leave a lasting impression on players. Each investigation brings a unique blend of narrative depth, moral ambiguity, and complex characters.

Let's start with "The Black Caesar." This case stands out because it dives deep into the seedy underbelly of Los Angeles' drug trade. I remember following the trail of a poisoning that led Phelps and Biggs to a counterfeit reefer distribution network. One of the most memorable aspects of this case is searching the coroner's office and discovering how ingeniously drugs were smuggled within food packaging. It's a moment that underscores the relentless creativity of the criminal underworld and makes players second-guess what they see on their grocery store shelves.

Next on our list is "The Set Up," a case that masterfully combines noir storytelling with intense gameplay. Here, I found myself embroiled in the dramatic life of boxer Albert Hammond. The case takes unexpected turns as it explores the fixed boxing matches in post-war Los Angeles. What makes this case particularly gripping are the high stakes and the intricate web of deceit involving not just Hammond but also his managers and promoters. The climactic confrontation in the gym, where Phelps connects the dots, is thrilling and satisfying for any detective.

However, it's "The Naked City" that truly epitomizes what makes the Vice Desk standout. This DLC case is inspired by the noir film of the same name and is a journey through the tragic life of a murdered aspiring actress. The atmosphere is palpable as you sift through her life, uncovering the exploitation and desperation she faced. I was particularly drawn to the interrogation scenes, where unwrapping the testimonies from various suspects, including corrupt doctors and jealous friends, highlighted the dark side of Hollywood's glamour. The case showcases excellent character development and emotional depth, making it unforgettable.

Even the seemingly straightforward "Manifest Destiny" offers layers of intrigue and action. I can't forget the adrenaline rush of infiltrating a drug shipment at the L.A. docks. The blend of action and detective work is perfectly balanced, culminating in a dramatic shootout. This case ties back to larger, insidious corruption within the police force and offers a potent conclusion to the Vice Desk's story arc.

In these Vice Desk cases, L.A. Noire doesn't shy away from depicting the gritty reality of 1940s Los Angeles. The investigations are more than just solving crimes; they are an exploration of human nature and societal issues, wrapped in engaging gameplay. Each case is a narrative experience that challenges players to think and empathize while keeping them on the edge of their seats.

Summary:

• Vice Desk investigations in L.A. Noire present compelling, morally complex cases that leave a lasting impression due to their narrative depth and complex characters.
• The Black Caesar explores L.A.'s drug trade, featuring a memorable coroner's office search that reveals drugs smuggled in food packaging.
• The Naked City is a DLC case that highlights Hollywood's dark side through the murder of an aspiring actress, showcasing excellent character development.

The Best Arson Desk Cases

When it comes to the L.A. Noire case files, the Arson Desk is filled with some of the most intense and gripping investigations you'll encounter. Here's a closer look at the best cases in this thrilling desk, giving you the most satisfying experiences in detective work.

"The Gas Man" stands out as one of the most intricately crafted cases in the Arson Desk. You start by investigating a devastating house fire that's resulted in a tragic loss of life. From the very beginning, the case hooks you with its emotional weight. One of the standout moments includes heading to Instinct Control Valve Company, where you need to piece together a faulty water heater mechanism. The level of detail in the environment makes it all the more immersive. Searching for clues in the ruins and questioning the bereaved family will keep you fully engaged throughout.

Another notable mention is "A Walk in Elysian Fields", which expertly combines intrigue and conspiracy. This case really ramps up the stakes as Phelps and Biggs uncover a shocking plot involving mass arson for the sake of real estate development. You'll find yourself exploring a suspiciously demolished suburban development, where the atmosphere is thick with tension. Sifting through the remnants of burnt homes and identifying a pattern to these fires will make you feel like a seasoned detective. A memorable scene is when you confront Leland Monroe, the shady real estate tycoon, who tries to keep his sinister operation under wraps. The dialogue is sharp, and the stakes feel very real.

Don't miss "House of Sticks", a case that delves into the murky waters of insurance fraud and betrayal. Here, you'll explore a series of incidents involving houses going up in flames under suspicious circumstances. One of the best moments is when you interview Kay Faraday, a witness with some crucial insights, and her testimony leads you to a surprising twist. The forensic analysis of burned sites and the subsequent chase to catch the arsonist provide the kind of intensity and satisfaction that makes L.A. Noire a standout title.

The climax of the Arson Desk, "A Polite Invitation", ties everything together in an explosive finale. In this case, the stakes skyrocket as you pursue powerful enemies who try to silence you. The action crescendos during a high-tension confrontation at the Elysian Fields site. Navigating through burning buildings and uncovering the final pieces of the puzzle offers a heart-pounding conclusion that will leave you thoroughly satisfied.

Each of these Arson Desk cases is meticulously crafted to deliver a rich and immersive detective experience. From intense interrogations to painstakingly gathering clues, these cases make the Arson Desk a memorable chapter in L.A. Noire.

Summary:

• "The Gas Man" stands out with an emotional investigation of a tragic house fire, detailed environments, and engaging clues and interviews.
• "A Walk in Elysian Fields" combines intrigue and conspiracy, exploring suburban arson for real estate gain, with tension-filled confrontations and uncovering patterns in fires.
• "House of Sticks" delves into insurance fraud, featuring intense forensic analysis, revealing interviews, and thrilling chases leading to a surprising twist.

Culmination of the Best Cases

The climax of our ranking, the culmination of the best cases in L.A. Noire, showcases the pinnacle of storytelling, gameplay mechanics, and emotional resonance. These cases are the epitome of what makes this game a timeless classic.

Let's start with the masterpiece, "The Quarter Moon Murders." This case is a melting pot of suspense, intricate puzzles, and memorable set pieces. We wander through landmarks, interpret cryptic clues from notorious poet Shelley, and confront a heinous serial killer. The unfolding mystery keeps us at the edge of our seats, making it one of the most unforgettable experiences in the game.

Next up is "The Silk Stocking Murder." This haunting case digs deep into the seedy underbelly of L.A.'s post-war society. The vision of the bloodied stocking and the carved messages on the victim's body send chills down our spines. The complexity and dark atmosphere make every moment visceral and gripping.

"A Different Kind of War" is another standout, notable for its intricately woven narrative that ties together the sprawling plot. This case serves as a crescendo, linking previous investigations and characters in a grand finale filled with explosive reveals and moral quandaries. The confrontations in the abandoned church are a thrilling mix of drama and action, ending the game on a high note.

Lastly, we cannot overlook "The Red Lipstick Murder." From its brutal opening scene to the relentless pursuit of the killer, this case excels in pacing and intensity. The detailed forensics and emotionally charged scenes with witnesses pull us deeper into the dark world of crime-solving.

Each of these cases sets a high bar, blending narrative depth with immersive gameplay. They epitomize the greatness of L.A. Noire and leave us yearning for more. These cases aren't just the best; they're the beating heart of what makes this game unforgettable.

Summary:

• "The Quarter Moon Murders" is a standout with its mix of suspense, puzzles, and memorable scenes, making it one of the most unforgettable experiences in L.A. Noire.
• "The Silk Stocking Murder" delivers a chilling exploration of L.A.'s dark post-war society, with complex, gripping elements that make the case visceral and haunting.
• "A Different Kind of War" and "The Red Lipstick Murder" both offer exceptional storytelling, with the former tying together the plot in an explosive finale, and the latter excelling in pacing and intensity.

Final Thoughts on L A Noire Case Rankings

When it comes to ranking all the cases in L.A. Noire, personal preferences undoubtedly influence the final standings. However, several critical factors come into play when determining the best and worst cases in this iconic game. From intricately woven narratives to the unique challenges each case presents, L.A. Noire's cases offer a variety of experiences that cater to different tastes.

It's essential to consider the story itself. Some cases, like "The Red Lipstick Murder," stand out due to their complex plotlines and depth of character development. This case, in particular, remains memorable due to its chilling atmosphere and the intense investigation involved. One can't overlook the emotional weight it carries, drawing you deeper into Phelps' world.

Gameplay mechanics also play a significant role in determining case rankings. A prime example is "The Driver's Seat." The balance between investigation, interrogation, and action sequences in this case keeps the player engaged throughout. The fresh challenges and unexpected twists push the boundaries of conventional gameplay, offering a rich, satisfying experience.

On the flip side, some cases might fall short due to either overly simplistic resolutions or less engaging storylines. "The Fallen Idol," for instance, although visually stunning, can feel a bit predictable compared to other cases. The straightforward nature of its puzzles might leave seasoned players craving more complexity.

The authenticity and attention to detail is another factor that can elevate a case. "A Polite Invitation" excels here, with its painstakingly recreated period settings and nuanced social interactions. Its ability to immerse the player in the post-war era Los Angeles is a testament to the developers' commitment to historical accuracy.

Ultimately, ranking the L.A. Noire cases is a subjective endeavor. Each player might favor different aspects of gameplay, narrative depth, or emotional impact. However, by considering factors such as story, gameplay, and authenticity, one can better appreciate the intricacies that make each case unique. The game’s strengths lie in its diversity, ensuring there’s something for every player to enjoy.

Summary:

• Ranking L.A. Noire cases involves personal preferences but requires considering narrative complexity, gameplay mechanics, and historical authenticity.
• Memorable cases like "The Red Lipstick Murder" offer deep plotlines and emotional weight, while "The Driver's Seat" balances investigation and action effectively.
• Some cases may fall short due to predictability or simplicity, but each case's unique qualities ensure a varied experience for every player.

Other Pages You Might Like: